Jackman’s ‘Death of Robin Hood’ Earns Fresh Rotten Tomatoes Score

“The Death of Robin Hood,” starring Hugh Jackman, Jodie Comer and Bill Skarsgård, is heading into its nationwide theatrical release on Friday with generally favorable reviews from critics. Directed and written by Michael Sarnoski, known for “Pig” and “A Quiet Place: Day One,” the R-rated reimagining of the legendary outlaw currently holds a 71% “fresh” rating on Rotten Tomatoes based on 79 critic reviews.

The film follows an older and severely wounded Robin Hood, portrayed by Jackman, who is left grappling with the consequences of a life marked by violence, crime and killing. As he recovers from his injuries under the care of the mysterious Sister Brigid, played by Comer, he is presented with an opportunity for redemption and self-reflection.

Several critics have praised Sarnoski’s darker and more intimate interpretation of the Robin Hood story. Richard Whittaker of the Austin Chronicle described the film as a version that recognizes the darkness that has always existed within the Robin Hood legend rather than artificially adding it. Cary Darling of the Houston Chronicle called the movie a haunting and emotionally resonant experience, while praising Jackman’s performance as a reserved and troubled protagonist.

Empire’s Ian Freer noted that despite the many adaptations of the Robin Hood tale over the years, Sarnoski succeeds in bringing new depth and humanity to the iconic character. Nikki Gemmell of The Australian also responded positively to the film’s craftsmanship, highlighting its costume design, musical score and cinematography, though she suggested the reflective screenplay occasionally slows the pace.

Not all reviewers were convinced by the film’s approach. Kyle Smith of The Wall Street Journal argued that the story loses momentum after its opening violence and struggles to convincingly portray the transformation at the center of the narrative. Katie Walsh of Tribune News Service criticized the film as lacking emotional and physical engagement, ultimately describing it as a dull exploration of mythology and storytelling.

Additional criticism came from Thelma Adams of AARP for Grownups, who wrote that despite the efforts of Jackman and Comer, the film is weighed down by its ambitions and seriousness. Mashable critic Kristy Puchko similarly dismissed the movie, calling it a difficult and cynical viewing experience despite its talented cast.

While the Rotten Tomatoes Critics Consensus, Audience Summary and verified audience Popcornmeter score have yet to be released, the film has secured a majority of positive reviews ahead of its debut. “The Death of Robin Hood” opens in theaters nationwide on Friday.